Share NoshOnIt


For us, cookies and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are the quintessential foods of childhood. This recipe is a 2-for-1 deal, combining both for a new classic! Rebeccah, Recipe Hunter

Rebeccah Marrero


PB & J Sandwich Cookies with Strawberry Marshmallow Cream Cheese Filling

This counts as lunch, right?

Is there a more iconic food pairing than peanut butter and jelly? The perfect after-school snack, PB&J sandwiches rank high on our list of comfort foods. Cookies (any and all!) are also near the top of the list. Fulfilling dreams we didn’t even know we had, Kimberly combines these two favorites to make some showstopping sandwich cookies. Peanut butter cookies make up the “bread” of this “sandwich,” with a filling of  whipped cream cheese and marshmallow cream, flavored with strawberry jam. For light, fluffy peanut butter cookies, make sure to fully cream the butter and sugar, incorporating more air in the batter. Taking the extra 5 minutes to complete that step ensures your cookies won’t break apart before being loaded with delicious marshmallow filling. Customize your filling by using whatever jam you have in the fridge. For the PB&J purists, grape jam may be the only way to go, but also try strawberry, raspberry, or even more unusual flavors like currant or plum.


Kimberly Killebrew

Mommy, Marriage & Family Therapist, The Daring Gourmet

Originally from Europe and widely traveled, my passion is world cuisine. I love developing original recipes, revitalizing classics, and demystifying the obscure. When I’m not visiting new places by foot, I’m traveling the world through my taste buds.

Kimberly is the creative voice, photographer, and recipe creator behind The Daring Gourmet. Spending her earlier years in Europe much of the dishes featured on her blog are inspired by international cuisines. Her recipes frequently feature homemade additions like creating raw spice blends or sauces to complement the more traditional ( and non-traditional) dishes. Kimberly is also a well traveled mother to two young kids and uses her culinary skills to create healthy alternatives to sweet treats and main course meals. From Indian infused dishes to Mexican inspired adaptations, Kimberly’s culinary genius is reflected in each one of her carefully crafted recipes.

Head over to The Daring Gourmet and say hello to Kimberly on TwitterFacebook,  and Pinterest.


The Easiest Way to Scoop Cookie Batter

To make even sized cookies easier to scoop, spray your spoon or ice cream scoop with non-stick cooking spray. The batter will slide right out!

Read the full tip >